If a call sounds like family
A plain-English look at one of the most common scam calls, and the habits families use to stay a step ahead.
What this call tends to sound like
These calls often come late, when people are tired. A young voice, upset or crying, that sounds like a grandchild, a son or a daughter. There has been an accident, an arrest, a hospital. There is a reason nobody else can be told. And there is only one way to help: money, quickly.
The voice may sound exactly right. Software can now copy a voice from a short clip, such as a voicemail greeting or a video posted online, and the copy can laugh, hesitate and say a name the way a family member would. That is why recognising a voice isn’t the reassurance it used to be. None of this is a failing on anyone’s part. These calls are designed to fool anyone.
The pattern these calls follow
Urgency + secrecy + money
- Urgency
- “It has to be tonight.”
- Secrecy
- “Please don’t tell Mom and Dad.”
- Money
- Gift cards, a wire transfer, cryptocurrency, or a courier sent to collect cash.
Any one of these can turn up in a real call. All three together is the shape of this scam.
Why a pause helps
These calls rely on urgency. The tears, the story and the deadline are all there to keep the person who answered from stopping to think. That is why so many of the habits families talk about come down to the same thing: a little time.
Things worth knowing
The pressure is part of the design.
A caller who insists there is no time at all is one of the most familiar features of these calls. The rush is how the scam works, whatever the story happens to be.
Calling back on a number you already have.
It’s the same habit many people use with any unexpected call, including one that claims to be from a bank: ending the call and ringing back on a number they already have, like the one saved in their phone or printed on their card, rather than one the caller offers. Banks and families really do call out of the blue sometimes; the habit simply means the next conversation happens on a line the person already trusts.
Why the secrecy matters.
“Don’t tell anyone” is there for a reason. A quick word with a parent, a partner or a brother or sister can bring in someone who knows where that person really is.
“My phone died, I’m on a friend’s.”
That can be true; phones do die. It is also a common line in these calls, because it explains away an unfamiliar number. A borrowed phone doesn’t change whether the person can be reached another way.
And if it really is an emergency?
That is the worry these calls lean on. Part of the appeal of a call back is that it goes straight to the real person, or the people around them, whichever kind of call it turns out to be.
A family code word
Some families agree on a code word, or more often a question and its answer, in person, before anyone ever needs it. The idea is to pick something a stranger couldn’t find online. Not the dog’s name, which is often all over social media, but a shared memory only the family would know.
The thinking behind it is simple. A voice can be copied. A shared memory can’t.
Setting one up can also be a gentle way to start talking about these calls, and it tends to work best when it covers everyone in the family, the grown-ups included. A forgotten answer in a moment of panic doesn’t prove anything either way, which is why many families treat the code word as one check alongside a call back, not instead of it.
“What did we always burn at the cabin?”
After a call like this
If you’re worried a payment has already been made, your bank or card provider and your local police deal with this every day and are the right people to talk to.
Offers to recover lost money for a fee are a well-known follow-up scam.
For every other kind of scam
This page looks at one kind of call. Is This Real? is our guidebook for the wider picture: the email from a company you really use, the video that looks like proof, the friendly investment that found you. It covers the moves that apply to all of them, a lab for practising them, and a family plan to fill in together.
A calm guidebook. One price, no subscription.